Nearly one million young people are outside education, employment or training. Today, Alan Milburn will argue that Britain can no longer afford to ignore the cost.
By Paul Cadman
Today, former Cabinet Minister Alan Milburn publishes what may become one of the most significant reports on youth opportunity and economic inactivity for a generation.
Its focus is a group often discussed politically but less frequently understood: the almost one million young people across the United Kingdom who are not in education, employment or training, commonly referred to as NEETs.
For government ministers, business leaders and educators, the numbers have become impossible to ignore. For the young people behind the statistics, the consequences can last a lifetime.
Milburn’s report arrives at a pivotal moment. The UK economy is struggling to accelerate growth, employers continue to report skills shortages across multiple sectors, and public finances remain under pressure. Yet despite businesses repeatedly highlighting recruitment challenges, hundreds of thousands of young people remain detached from the labour market.
The question at the heart of today’s report is deceptively simple: how can Britain have workforce shortages and nearly one million young people disconnected from work and learning at the same time?
A Problem Decades in the Making
The data presents a worrying picture.
Since the pandemic, the number of young people classified as NEET has been steadily rising. In many respects this reverses the progress achieved following the 2008 financial crisis, when sustained efforts helped reduce the number of young people outside education, employment and training.
However, the longer-term trend may be even more concerning.
For almost the entirety of the last quarter century, Britain’s NEET rate has rarely fallen below 10 per cent. Governments of all political colours have introduced initiatives, programmes and funding streams, yet the challenge has remained stubbornly persistent. Temporary improvements have come and gone, but the underlying issue has never truly been solved.
International comparisons make Britain’s position particularly uncomfortable.
Across Europe, countries such as the Netherlands have reduced their NEET rates to below four per cent, while Ireland has achieved one of the most remarkable turnarounds on the continent, moving from near the bottom of the rankings to become one of the strongest performers over the last decade.
The United Kingdom, meanwhile, has drifted in the opposite direction.
It is against this backdrop that Milburn is calling for what he describes as a “whole-system reset”, designed to dramatically reduce the number of young people disconnected from work and learning and put Britain back on a competitive footing with its international peers.
His ambition is bold. Without meaningful intervention, forecasts suggest the proportion of young people classified as NEET is likely to remain broadly unchanged over the next decade. Milburn believes significant reform could dramatically reduce those numbers and move Britain towards what he terms “NEET Zero”.
This Is Not a Generation of Shirkers
Perhaps the most compelling aspect of the report is that it challenges many of the assumptions surrounding the young people at its centre.
The evidence suggests this is not primarily a story about a generation lacking ambition or work ethic.
Almost three-quarters of young people classified as NEET say they want a job.
Many possess qualifications. Around a third have achieved five good GCSEs, including English and mathematics. Despite this, they remain disconnected from employment opportunities.
The challenge is not simply education.
It is access to opportunity.
One statistic in particular stands out.
Nearly two-thirds of young people currently classed as NEET have never had a job.
Not lost a job.
Not left the workforce.
Never entered it.
That figure has risen sharply over the past two decades and points towards a growing structural challenge within the labour market. The longer someone remains outside work, the harder it becomes to gain that crucial first opportunity. Employers seek experience. Young people struggle to obtain it. Confidence falls, aspirations diminish and inactivity becomes harder to escape.
The Health Factor
Health represents another major factor.
Much attention has focused on the growing number of young people reporting disabilities, mental health conditions, autism and learning difficulties.
The numbers have risen markedly in recent years.
However, Milburn argues that the increase in health conditions alone does not explain the growth in youth inactivity. More revealing is the fact that young people with disabilities are becoming economically inactive at a much faster rate than the wider population.
Put simply, while more young people may now be recognised as having additional needs, the systems designed to help them secure employment have failed to keep pace.
The report suggests that disabled young people are now significantly more likely to find themselves trapped outside education, employment and training than they were a decade ago.
Lost to the System
The report also challenges assumptions surrounding welfare dependency.
Public debate often assumes that most young people who are economically inactive are heavily reliant on benefits.
The reality is considerably more nuanced.
Almost half of young people classified as NEET are not claiming benefits at all.
For Milburn, this may be the most concerning group of all. These are young people who are neither participating in the labour market nor engaging with support systems. In many respects they have become invisible to government and public services, making intervention significantly more difficult.
At the same time, the report identifies what Milburn describes as the defining shift of the last decade.
Historically, youth unemployment was the central concern.
Today, economic inactivity presents the greater challenge.
Young people are increasingly not just unemployed but entirely detached from the labour market. They are no longer actively seeking work, often citing repeated rejection, poor health, a lack of opportunity or a belief that suitable employment simply does not exist.
Their frustrations appear to have substance.
Entry-level vacancies have fallen considerably. Employers continue to report concerns about work readiness and skills shortages, while businesses also face increased employment costs and uncertainty surrounding the impact of technology and artificial intelligence on the future workplace.
Why the West Midlands Should Care
For regions such as the West Midlands, the implications are profound.
The region continues to position itself as a national centre for advanced manufacturing, professional services, logistics, construction, technology and green industries. Billions of pounds are being invested in economic development, skills and regeneration.
Yet many young people remain disconnected from the opportunities being created.
Business leaders across the West Midlands have consistently highlighted concerns around workforce development, employability and the shrinking number of entry-level opportunities. At the same time, colleges, universities and training providers have warned that increasing numbers of young people face barriers linked to poor mental health, disability, low confidence and social isolation.
The challenge is not a lack of ambition. Significant investment has been made in apprenticeships, technical education, skills bootcamps and employer-led training programmes. Yet Milburn’s findings suggest the gap between qualification and employment continues to widen for many young people.
Professor Paul Cadman, Executive Chairman of Walk Through Walls and a long-standing advocate for creating pathways into employment and enterprise, believes the debate can no longer be reduced to statistics alone.
“Behind every percentage point is a young person whose potential is being lost. The West Midlands has extraordinary opportunities ahead of it, but those opportunities mean very little if increasing numbers of young people cannot see a route into them. Businesses, educators and policymakers all have a role to play, but we need to stop treating this as somebody else’s problem. A generation is waiting for an opportunity and we cannot afford to leave them behind.”
The Cost of Doing Nothing
Milburn’s conclusion is that Britain has become too focused on managing the consequences of youth disengagement and not focused enough on preventing it.
One of the report’s most striking observations is that the country spends significantly more supporting people after they have become disconnected than it does helping them gain the skills and opportunities needed to enter employment in the first place.
Compared with many developed nations, Britain is increasingly an outlier.
His solution is a substantial rebalancing towards earlier intervention, personalised support, vocational pathways, skills development and stronger engagement between employers, educators and government.
The economic stakes are enormous.
The annual cost of youth inactivity stretches far beyond welfare spending. It includes lost productivity, reduced tax revenues and vast amounts of untapped economic potential. Every young person who fails to enter the labour market represents a loss not only to themselves but to the country as a whole.
Yet beyond the economics lies an even bigger question.
What happens to a society when increasing numbers of young people lose confidence that they can participate in its future success?
Setting the Scene for Today
That is the question sitting behind Alan Milburn’s report as it is unveiled today.
His recommendations are expected to challenge long-held assumptions, expose uncomfortable truths and call for a fundamental reset in how government, employers, educators and communities work together. There will undoubtedly be debate around welfare reform, skills investment, health support and employer responsibility.
But the bigger story is impossible to ignore.
Nearly one million young people are not in education, employment or training. Most say they want a job. Many possess qualifications. A growing number face health challenges. Almost two-thirds have never experienced the workplace at all.
The evidence increasingly suggests Britain is no longer facing a temporary labour market challenge. It is confronting a generational crisis of opportunity.
When Alan Milburn takes to the stage later today, attention will naturally focus on his proposals. Yet the significance of the report extends far beyond policy recommendations.
It is a challenge to government, business and society alike.
After decades of persistently high levels of youth disengagement, Britain stands at a crossroads. Continue managing the consequences of exclusion, or fundamentally rethink how opportunity is created, shared and accessed.
For the West Midlands, a region built on industry, resilience, enterprise and aspiration, the stakes could hardly be higher.
The question is no longer whether Britain has a youth opportunity problem.
The question is whether today’s report becomes the catalyst for change, or simply another warning added to a growing pile of evidence that the country can no longer afford to ignore.
